From the screenshots shared, I think this game is on live BBG and has never been changed to static. so you guys had the changes for bbg 6.0 and 6.1 into the game.
I suggest you guys deciding which one works best for you. either 5.8 or 6.1 and switch to static one.
Right now, game is on live BBG. let me know if you need help but this is a guide on how to switch mods: